Ah, the made-for-TV movie. Even as the golden era ended at the turn of the century, stations like TBS kept gifting the world with these treasures.
Quick Plot: Nothing unites a new family like a road trip! Dad Jim (my early Clash of the Titans crush Harry Hamlin) is hoping that some Nevada desert will warm his nice teen son Matt and bitter tween daughter Katie to his new wife Patty (The Partridge Family's Susan Dey), a book editor with a cell phone (slightly ahead of the curve in 2002). Also in tow is Matt's pal Ethan.
After stopping for terrible burgers at a greasy diner filled with ominous locals, budding photographer Matt convinces his family to take a detour to an abandoned mining village. It's a fun hour spent wandering a mysteriously empty main street but also just enough time to cause some car trouble. The family makes a camping trip out of it with a sense of adventure until they discover a dusty video camera with some early found footage home movie of the last group to open their sleeping bags in the same house.
Things look worse in the morning when the car goes missing. Yes, these hills have eyes, and they're not smiling.
Made for the TBS Superstation (THROWBACK!), Disappearance is a curious piece of cinema (well, small screen cinema). The film is written and directed by TV veteran Walter Klenhard, a man with dozens of Garage Sale Mystery credits to his name, plus the irresistibly titled Baby Monitor: Sound of Fear.
I've been talking a lot about one's level of expectation when approaching a genre film. Standards change depending on budget and ambition. They also get very skewed when we're talking about a television network that hasn't aired its own film content in twenty years.
Like any TV movie, Disappearance shows its format with some commercial fade outs and a fairly clear TV-14 limit. But it's also filmed in the sprawling Australian outback and has an aura of something slightly bigger. The cast is strong, and that includes the younger actors who feel quite lived in and comfortable as this family. There's a kind of YA literature energy to how things go down, which I mean as a compliment.
I think a lot of viewers, both from 2002 and 2025, won't find much in Disappearance. But if you go into it with an open mind and fondness for a time when the letters TBS had a certain ring, you might, as I did, walk away having had a surprisingly good, albeit confusing time.
High Points
The combination of good writing and confident performances from young Jer Adrianne Lelliott as Matt and Basia A'Hern (who went on to do editorial work for Furiosa, which is pretty badass) as Katie really do help to make the family antics of Disappearance work well
Low Points
I love a good ambiguous ending, but it's genuinely bizarre how little a made-for-TBS thriller ends up disclosing. I have no idea what actually happened in this movie, which is admirably daring on Klenhard's part, but incredibly unsatisfying on mine